Common mistakes PMs make when A/B testing

Posted on 4/28/2023, 5:23:49 PM

As a product manager, A/B testing is an essential tool to help you understand how your customers behave and what they want. A/B testing involves comparing two different versions of a product or feature to see which performs better. It's a powerful way to make data-driven decisions, but it's also easy to make mistakes. In this article, we'll look at some of the most common mistakes product managers make when conducting an A/B test and how to avoid them.

Testing too many variables at once

Testing too many variables at once is a common mistake made by product managers who are eager to learn as much as possible from a single test. However, the more variables you test, the harder it becomes to determine which change caused the observed results. For example, let's say you run an A/B test on an e-commerce website to determine whether changing the color and the size of a "Buy Now" button will increase the conversion rate. If you test both variables simultaneously and see a significant increase in conversion rates, you won't be able to tell which change was responsible for the improvement. Was it the color or the size of the button? Testing one variable at a time would help you identify the exact factor that impacted the conversion rate.

Ignoring statistical significance

Statistical significance is the degree to which the results of an experiment are likely to be true and not just due to chance. Many product managers make the mistake of ignoring statistical significance when conducting an A/B test. They may see a difference in the results between the two versions but not realize that the difference is not statistically significant. It's important to pay attention to statistical significance to ensure that the results are valid.

For example, let's say you run an A/B test on a landing page to determine whether adding a video improves engagement. If you notice a slight increase in engagement on the page with the video, but the difference is not statistically significant, you cannot conclude that the video is responsible for the improvement. It could be due to chance or other factors, such as seasonal changes, that impact user behavior.

Not considering the sample size

The sample size is the number of people who participate in the A/B test. A common mistake that product managers make is not considering the sample size when conducting an A/B test. If the sample size is too small, the results may not be accurate. It's important to ensure that the sample size is large enough to get statistically significant results.

For example, let's say you run an A/B test on a new feature on your mobile app and test it on a small group of users. You notice that the engagement rate for the new feature is significantly higher than the existing feature. However, if the sample size is too small, you cannot be confident that this difference is not due to chance.

Not testing for long enough

Testing for a sufficient period is critical to ensure that your results are stable and not affected by external factors that change over time. For example, let's say you run an A/B test on an e-commerce website to determine whether changing the layout of the homepage will increase sales. You run the test for a week and notice a significant increase in sales on the new homepage layout. However, if you had run the test for a longer period, you might have noticed that the increase in sales was due to a seasonal uptick in shopping behavior that had nothing to do with the new layout.

Not considering the context

Context is a critical factor in A/B testing. The same change that works well in one context may not work well in another. For example, let's say you run an A/B test on a landing page to determine whether changing the headline will improve engagement. You notice that the new headline performs better than the old one, but when you test it on a different audience, you see no improvement. The context of the test is critical here. The two audiences may have different preferences, expectations, and demographics that impact how they respond to different headlines.

Need career advice? Book a call with a mentor at mentordial.com.

In conclusion, A/B testing is a powerful tool for product managers, but it's easy to make mistakes that can lead to inaccurate results. By avoiding these common mistakes and taking a methodical and rigorous approach to A/B testing, you can ensure that your tests provide accurate and valuable insights that can help you make data-driven decisions